How to Check Your Out-of-Network Benefits Before You Book

Home > Check Your Out-of-Network Benefits

Fifteen minutes on the phone before your first appointment will tell you what a year of treatment actually costs. Most people skip it and find out from the first Explanation of Benefits.

Before you call

Have your insurance card. Call the member services number on the back — not the provider line — and say you're asking about out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits.

Say "mental health" specifically. Behavioral health benefits are frequently administered by a separate company from your medical benefits, and the general representative may quote you the wrong numbers.

The eight questions

1. Does my plan include out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits?
If no, stop here — nothing else matters and no superbill will help. HMO and EPO plans typically have no out-of-network coverage. PPO and POS plans usually do.

2. What is my out-of-network deductible, and how much of it have I met this year?
Separate from and usually higher than your in-network deductible. Commonly $1,000–$5,000 for an individual. Money paid toward one does not count toward the other.

3. After the deductible, what percentage do you reimburse for out-of-network outpatient mental health?
This is the number people remember and the one that misleads. Write it down, then ask question 4 — which is the one that actually determines your cost.

4. What is the allowed amount for CPT codes 90792, 99204, 99214, and 90836 in ZIP code 10011? And how is it determined?

This is the question almost nobody asks and it decides everything.

Your insurer reimburses a percentage of the allowed amount — its own internally determined rate, also called UCR (usual, customary and reasonable) or MRC (maximum reimbursable charge) — not a percentage of what you were charged.

Ask how it's set. Common answers: a percentile of a regional fee database (FAIR Health), or a multiple of the Medicare rate. If they say "a percentage of Medicare," ask what multiple. Representatives sometimes claim they can't provide this. Ask again, ask for a supervisor, and note that you're asking about your own plan's terms.

5. Is preauthorization required for outpatient psychiatric care?
Uncommon for outpatient psychiatry, not unheard of. Skipping a required preauthorization means an automatic denial.

6. What is the deadline for submitting an out-of-network claim?
Ranges from 90 days to a full year. Missing it forfeits the claim entirely, and this is the most common avoidable loss.

7. Is telehealth covered at the same rate as in-person?
Usually yes now. Confirm, and ask whether place-of-service code 10 or 02 changes anything.

8. What is my out-of-network out-of-pocket maximum?
For anyone anticipating a year of weekly treatment, this is the ceiling that matters.

Before hanging up: ask for a reference number for the call, and the representative's name.

Doing the arithmetic

Take what you learned and run it:

Fee charged (ask the practice):            $ ______
Insurer's allowed amount (Q4):             $ ______
Coinsurance after deductible (Q3):           ____ %
Out-of-network deductible remaining (Q2):  $ ______

Reimbursement per visit, after deductible:
  allowed amount × coinsurance %         =  $ ______

Your net cost per visit:
  fee charged − reimbursement            =  $ ______

Visits until deductible is met:
  deductible remaining ÷ allowed amount  =    ______

A worked example. Charged $500, allowed amount $200, coinsurance 70%, deductible met: you receive $140 and pay $360. Your effective coverage is 28%, not 70%.

If your deductible is $3,000 and the allowed amount is $200, it takes fifteen visits before any money comes back — and those visits accrue at $200 each toward the deductible, not at the $500 you paid.

Then ask the practice two things

"What are your fees for an initial evaluation and for follow-up visits?"

"Will you provide a Good Faith Estimate in writing?" Under the federal No Surprises Act, providers must furnish one to self-pay and uninsured patients before scheduled care. If your final bill exceeds it by $400 or more, there's a formal dispute pathway.

A practice that won't put its fees in writing is telling you something.

If the numbers don't work

That's a legitimate finding, and it's better to have it now.

An in-network psychiatrist is a reasonable choice — often the better one if your presentation is straightforward and cost is a real constraint. Reduced-fee options exist through training clinics at academic medical centers, where you're seen by a supervised resident or fellow. Some practices offer sliding scales; asking costs nothing.

Related

What out-of-network psychiatric care costs in Manhattan · What a superbill is and how to use it · What an ADHD evaluation costs · How to choose a psychiatrist

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find out if my insurance covers out-of-network therapy?

Call the member services number on your insurance card and ask specifically about out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits. Behavioral health is often administered separately from medical benefits, so specify.

What is an allowed amount?

The rate your insurer has internally determined a service should cost — also called UCR or MRC. Your reimbursement is a percentage of that figure, not of the fee you were charged, and it's frequently well below market rates in Manhattan.

My plan says it covers 70% out-of-network. Why did I only get $140 back on a $500 visit?

Because 70% applies to the allowed amount, not the charge. If the allowed amount is $200, 70% is $140. That gap is the single largest source of unexpected cost in out-of-network care.

Do HMO plans cover out-of-network mental health care?

Typically not. HMO and EPO plans generally provide no out-of-network coverage, so a superbill has nothing to pay against. PPO and POS plans usually do include it.

What if the representative won't tell me the allowed amount?

Ask again, request a supervisor, and note that you're asking about the terms of your own plan. If you still can't get it, ask what percentile of what fee database or what multiple of Medicare they use — which lets you estimate.

What is a Good Faith Estimate?

A written estimate of expected charges that providers must furnish to self-pay and uninsured patients before scheduled care under the No Surprises Act. If the final bill exceeds it by $400 or more, a formal dispute process is available.